Letters to the Editor

Bank erosion to blame for narrowing McCallum

Some say the lower reaches of the McCallum Ditch are natural (1905 map) and should remain that way as it provides habitat for species at risk, frogs and fish. The fact is that on October 9,1895 (yes that's 18 not 19) a Plan and Memorandum of the Agassiz Ditching Scheme was filed at the Land Registry Office in New Westminster, B.C.  Kent Reeve, Alfred St. George Hamersley set out to ditch and dyke the area for flood control and irrigation purposes; this was the original sole purpose for the McCallum Ditch.

Today it is a collector ditch that collects water from many areas, from the Research Station to Harrison all the way to the base of Woodside Mountain. Over the years other water has been added to the McCallum Drainage System, the Corrections  Canada lands drain into the McCallum as does some Industrial  land and some other hard surface properties. Fish and frogs have probably been in the ditches for a long time and have done quite well, but now there numbers are declining due to low levels of dissolved oxygen. By not removing sediment to increase flows things will get worse for the fish and frogs as well as the farmer. Those involved with the approval process for ditch maintenance are further endangering the habitat for aquatic species. This non-sense of shading ditches to remove reed canary won't work very well as it grows back rapidly and/or black berry bushes can take over. Then there is the over application of manure. Today there is much more on farm storage than ever before, and farmers see it as a valuable fertilizer than a waste product.

The narrowing of the main channel has occurred from sediment deposits from bank failures not from landowner infilling. Farmers have done land improvements, over the generations, to help insure viability of their farms. I know Biologists who have dumped many large truck loads of wood waste into the McCallum and Mountain watersheds to use in habitat restoration projects which further impede flows. Gravel that has mined off the hillside is solid rock that is then crushed down to smaller sizes and is used in the construction industry. Impervious surfaces don't have much absorption  or filtering capacities.

I hope that more than just farm practices can be improved to facilitate better drainage, and I hope those involved in the approval process can see that drainage and fish/frog habitat can co-exist together.

Sincerely,

Dairy Farmer,

Species at Risk Habitat Provider,

Agassiz Harrison Mills Drainage Comm. Chair

District of Kent Councillor

Duane Post

We encourage an open exchange of ideas on this story's topic, but we ask you to follow our guidelines for respecting community standards. Personal attacks, inappropriate language, and off-topic comments may be removed, and comment privileges revoked, per our Terms of Use. Please see our FAQ if you have questions or concerns about using Facebook to comment.
Battle wages on over Salmon River diversion
 
Why not ban sale of cigarettes?
 
Looking for their reasons to riot

Community Events, September 2014

Add an Event

Read the latest eEdition

Browse the print edition page by page, including stories and ads.

Sep 11 edition online now. Browse the archives.